The Ethical Requirements of Space Activities.
A review of the document Outer Space and Humanity at a Crossroads: Reflections on a New Frontier of the Common Good.

Nouvelles théologiques | 20/11/2026 | All the Nouvelles théologiques

Dominique Lambert

 

Excess satellites, orbital debris, the race for lunar resources, the risk of space militarization: humanity stands at a crossroads. In a groundbreaking study, the Caritas in Veritate Foundation—which is affiliated with the Holy See’s Mission to the UN—proposes reviving the spirit of the 1967 Outer Space Treaty.

Pen-and-ink portrait of Dominique Lambert
The goal is to preserve this space as free, peaceful, and shared by all, and to extend integral ecology to it.

Dominique Lambert, professor emeritus at the University of Namur and member of the Royal Academy of Belgium (Class of Sciences), presents this document, which aims to make the “common sky” a place of peace and brotherhood. Listen to his interview with Vincent Delcorps and Clément Laloyaux, on the “Pleins Feux” program aired on April 20, 2026, on Cathobel.


The Nouvelles théologiques are free. But we need your help. Support the NRT by subscribing or signing up a loved one.
Enjoy a 40% discount with the code 2026-40 (100% digital or print-digital. Valid through 12/31/2026 for a first-time, 1-year subscription).
Subscribe
book
Cover of the document Outer Space and Humanity at a Crossroads featuring an image from the James Webb Space Telescope ©

Shortly before the publication of the encyclical Magnifica Humanitas, the Caritas in Veritate Foundation—which works closely with the Holy See’s Observer Mission to the UN (Geneva)—published a document titled: Outer Space and Humanity at a Crossroads. Reflections on a New Frontier of the Common Good1. In the context of the Catholic Church, this is a pioneering study on the foundations of an ethics for activities taking place in outer space.

This document, with a foreword by the Secretary of State, Cardinal Pietro Parolin, and introduced by an editorial note from Professor Paola Gianotti, who served as Director of CERN from 2016 to 2025, concludes with a selection of papal addresses and Holy See declarations on space-related issues, introduced by Father Richard Anthony D’Souza, director of the Vatican Observatory.

I Space: Threatened and Coveted

In recent years, outer space has seen an increasing number of satellites in low or more distant orbits. This is because our activities on Earth have become extremely dependent on satellites. Our highly interconnected world can no longer do without communications that travel not only through undersea cables but also via satellite constellations designed to cover increasingly vast regions of the globe. Geographic positioning (GPS in particular) also requires the use of satellites. We could also mention their uses for climatological observations (to prevent natural disasters, for example) or demographic studies, as well as for surveillance to ensure compliance with disarmament treaties or to document war crimes…

It is also clear that satellites play a crucial role in the militarization (militarization) of space through tactical or strategic observations and missile guidance, among other things, and could also be used to deploy space-based weapons (weaponization). The situation is, moreover, complex, since civilian satellites can also, through dual-use applications, serve this militarization or weaponization of space.

As the document’s subtitle indicates, humanity stands at a crossroads. Indeed, this overuse of outer space poses very significant problems. The vast amount of debris of all sizes—traveling at high speeds—from satellites that have reached the end of their operational life, launch vehicle components, or the result of anti-satellite weapon tests, is beginning to dangerously contaminate orbital paths. Missions to the International Space Station and spacewalks by astronauts could be made impossible by the risk of collision with this debris. Furthermore, the large number of spacecraft risks significantly disrupting astronomical observations, narrowing the scope of scientific inquiry. Already, certain observations can no longer be made from Earth due to pollution in regions of the electromagnetic spectrum used by astronomers. Compounding these problems is a race for profit that is driving the commercialization and privatization of space, as well as projects to exploit space resources (on asteroids, on the Moon, etc.) by private companies linked to powerful nations. Dreams of these companies monopolizing space—at the expense of those who cannot afford launch vehicles and space missions—are emerging and seem to be reenacting a neocolonial logic in these new, uncharted territories.

We are therefore at a crossroads, for there is still time to curb this trend toward privatization, shameless exploitation, pollution, militarization, and the arming of outer space—and to give ourselves the opportunity to avoid repeating in these new territories mistakes similar to those that have led us, here on Earth, to catastrophes (pollution, wars, colonization, etc.).

II The 1967 Treaty: Space as a Common Good

But how can this be done? In fact, the document from the Caritas in Veritate Foundation points to a solid path forward. Far from prohibiting space activities that are extremely useful to humanity (we can no longer do without space!) and healthy competition among nations and scientists, it calls for a revival of the spirit of the 1967 Outer Space Treaty (Outer Space Treaty), which remains in force today. It is, in fact, an important legal instrument that regulates space activities at the international level.

The guidelines of this Treaty—which, incidentally, are reminiscent of those regulating activities in Antarctica or the deep ocean—are as follows:

1) Outer space must be freely accessible to all. Therefore, certain nations cannot be prohibited from exploring areas of this space.
2) Nor can any private company—or any nation, no matter how powerful—claim ownership of a region of space.
3) States, not private companies, are liable for any damage caused during space activities.
4) Space must be used for peaceful purposes (for example, placing nuclear weapons in orbit is out of the question).
5) Space must remain a common good, whose resources must benefit everyone.

III A Space Ecology in the Service of Peace and Fraternity

The document from the Caritas in Veritate Foundation complements these guidelines by emphasizing that outer space is also a “Common Sky”—a landscape open to contemplation that has inspired philosophers, poets, and artists. It advocates extending integral terrestrial ecology to a “spatial ecology” in which the protection of extraterrestrial sites is also taken into account. The document does not oppose the exploitation of certain space sites, should the need arise for the survival of humanity, but it does oppose a conception that would run counter to the universal destination of goods by allowing the unilateral appropriation of resources for the benefit of specific economic or state powers.

A page from the document, featuring an image of the James Webb Space Telescope ©

It also emphasizes that space exploration must remain compatible with the sustainable development of science and scientific observations. Another important point is the emphasis on supporting and developing major international scientific projects that foster—as is the case on the International Space Station, but also at major scientific institutions such as CERN—a genuine spirit of brotherhood in the service of science and peace. The 1967 Outer Space Treaty, in fact, referred to astronauts as “envoys of humanity”—sent to work together and for the good of all, without philosophical, political, religious, or national distinctions…

Regarding military matters, the Holy See’s Mission document calls for strict adherence to international humanitarian law in any conflict that might involve space. This point is important, as we know that a localized conflict in space could impact a large portion of civilian activities and cause harm to a large number of non-combatants.

Finally, the document addresses the issue of respecting the dignity of those who are traveling and will travel into space. Humans have always dreamed of exploring unknown “lands,” and taking risks is part of any exploratory adventure. However, crewed missions cannot be accepted if it is known with certainty that they will place the crews in grave danger. The sole objective of asserting national or military power cannot justify a serious violation of human dignity. Respect for the physiological limits of space explorers must be a fundamental consideration. The document from the Caritas in Veritate Foundation notes that the 1967 Treaty contains certain ambiguities and gaps. It recommends maintaining the Treaty (which should not be renegotiated because its principles are essential) and adding an additional protocol that could bring it up to date:

1) clarify the meaning of certain terms (for example, what exactly does “peaceful use” of space mean?),
2) address new issues (exploitation of resources, commercialization of space, arming of satellites),
3) propose robust mechanisms for enforcing the Treaty’s provisions at the international level.

The document Outer Space and Humanity at a Crossroads is intended as a proposal to enrich the ethical, legal, and diplomatic debate, with a view to discerning the path to take at this crossroads so that this new space opening up to humanity may be one of peace, fraternity, and respect for the common good and the common space…

The document was presented in Geneva (UN) on February 13, 2026; at COMECE (Brussels) on June 9, 2026; and in Vienna (UNOOSA and the Holy See’s Permanent Mission to the International Organizations in Vienna) during the International Peace Day on September 21, 2026. It will also be presented at a conference in Rome in January 2027.

In an upcoming issue of the Nouvelle revue théologique, we will discuss in greater detail several of the ethical issues raised here by the expansion of human activities in outer space, in order to explore their implications and challenges more deeply.


1. Download the document as a PDF: Outer Space and Humanity at a Crossroads. Reflections on a New Frontier of the Common Good.

 

newsletter


the journal


NRT is a quarterly journal published by a group of Theology professors, under the supervision of the Society of Jesus in Brussels.

contact


Nouvelle revue théologique
Boulevard Saint-Michel, 24
1040 Bruxelles, Belgium